7A Testing the Hypothesis Part 1

Musicians forgetting their music or lyrics on stage
·     When performing on stage, some musicians and singers need their words or chords to be displayed to help them perform to their best ability. However, looking at a chord chart or screen can make it feel like they are not prepared or connected with their audience.
o  The who: onstage performers
o  The what: they don’t remember every single lyric or chord they need to sing or play.
o  The why: either they do not know, become nervous and forget, or the set is exceptionally long, and it is hard to remember what is coming next.
·     Testing the who: This can also be spread out to actors and speakers that need help with points and lines on stage.
·     Testing the what: not everyone has this problem. Some performers can remember everything that they need to know.
·     Testing the why: there are a lot of different reasons why people will forget stuff they should know. It’s hard to explain, but sometimes when people get nervous, their thought processes seem to disappear.
Interviews:
·     The fist I interviewed was my coworker at my home church. She went to college for music. She has been performing on stage since she graduated. The first few words to sing are the hardest for her to remember. Since songs normally run in patterns, she can figure the rest once she gets started. She gets nervous when she gets a solo. She doesn’t experience the problem usually, but there is a screen in the back of the room with the current slide and the words coming up next when she does need it. The hardest part for her is communicating to others that she does not know lyrics when there is no cheatsheet available. 
·     The second person I interviewed was my boss at my home church. He thought of the situation differently because his job is to lead worship. He tries his hardest to memorize everything he has to perform, he feels it is expected of him. He finds it distracting to the audience when he has to look at a screen or piece of paper to help cue him.
·      I interviewed a pastor to understand an outsider’s perspective. He said he noticed when others were using a piece of paper to help keep them on track. He noted that he didn’t see when they were looking at the screen in the back, but it was terrible when it located right in front of the stage. He said it was pronounced when they would look down. He did not mind it if they were natural about it. 
·     The next person I interviewed was a sound technician. He also provided me with an outsider’s perspective. He said that it was apparent when performers did not memorize lyrics. He doesn’t like when they have to move papers around, because a lot of people notice the hands moving and it distracts them from the focus of worship. He feels like they did not practice enough and doesn’t get connected to the singer. 
·     The last person I interviewed was someone in the band I used to play in. He does typically well with remembering, but now that he is leading the band gets stressed out. He has to think of a lot of moving parts, and he worries more that everything stays afloat. When he stresses out, he forgets the words, because his mind starts to wander to other places. He cannot get connected with the audience for these reasons. He wishes there was a way to use cheatsheets without it being a distraction to others.
Opportunities you did not notice till now:
·      I am not the only person to have a problem, there are times when we forget lyrics. My boss is practically a walking jukebox, it was surprising that he sometimes needs the screen in the back to help guide him. 
·      I asked the sound technician if he noticed when I used the screen and my chord charts, and I rely on it very bad. I thought it was fine, but it is to the point where it is disengaging. 
·      I did not realize that is was off putting looking at the screen was, it hindered some not to be able to worship. They feel as if I am singing to the screen instead of the audience. 

·      I feel that the real solution is to know what you are singing, but sometimes that is not possible with the number of songs people play during some church services.

Comments

  1. Grant, you have not idea how much I relate to this. I played in my church worship band for about 13 years and I never liked the look of the papers on the stands for the singers. The lead singer usually would memorize but many times I had noticed they forgot the words and they either made new ones up completely or pretended to be captivated by the spirit haha! I have also been the singer/guitarist of a band for many years and we have performed in very large venues. I was in charge of writing up the set lists with sharpie every day for every member and it felt so tedious and unnecessary. If there would have been a screen for everyone to see, I feel like there would have been a lot less confusion overall.
    Here is a clip of my band if you wanna check us out! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qitcLmkJO24

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Grant!

    I also feel like this is a big problem as it makes the musician seem that they do not care about their work and are not passionate about their music which is really sad. It reminds me of how performers often lip sync because it is easier for them to just mover their mouth. I feel like they are taking away the experience that their fans paid for. I think your opportunity can turn into something special if you continue on the right track.

    Awesome Post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Grant! I think you did an awesome job on this assignment. I totally agree with you that when a musician on stage play and looks down at a chart to read over the music or lyrics, it definitely makes it seem to the audience that they are not prepared. You definitely did a great job with the people who you interviewed and got great input from them! Great job.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your interviews gave you great insight about your opportunity. I think it is interesting that most of the people that you interviewed said that it was distracting when performers read off of paper during their performance. You selected a good group of people to interview with a variety of different perspectives about the problem and how the problem affects different parties.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment